In a rare show of support, farmer Craig McIntosh has offered to host the VNI West transmission lines on his property, a bold move that has sparked both praise and criticism. With 4,000 hectares at Tragowel, near Kerang, McIntosh is a vocal supporter of the controversial 500-kilometre high-voltage project, which aims to connect renewable energy zones in Victoria and New South Wales. This project has faced opposition from many farmers, including Victorian Farmers Federation (VFF) president Brett Hosking, who argues that the transmission lines impose stress and limit farmers' input over land use.
McIntosh's support stems from his experience farming around an existing transmission line for 60 years, which has brought power to the region. He believes that the VNI West project is necessary to modernize the energy infrastructure and prevent further delays. By hosting 10km of transmission line, McIntosh stands to receive over $2 million in state government compensation over 25 years, diversifying his income and helping to drought-proof his property. This compensation would also enable a proposed wind turbine facility on his land, generating additional income.
However, the project has faced criticism from Professor Bruce Mountain of the Victoria Energy Policy Centre, who estimates the cost at up to $28 billion and argues for cheaper alternatives. Mountain's "Plan B" involves using existing grid upgrades and higher voltage, which he claims undermines the energy transition and imposes significant costs on consumers. Despite the opposition, VicGrid chief executive Alistair Parker emphasizes the project's importance for Victoria's energy security, stating that they will continue to engage respectfully and seek voluntary agreements for access.
The VNI West project has encountered challenges, with survey access provided for only 40% of the preferred easement and access denied on 26 properties. If access is refused, authorized officers may issue warnings or infringement notices, and VicGrid can even apply for a court order. However, Parker reassures that refusing access does not halt the project but may require assumptions to fill information gaps. McIntosh's willingness to host the transmission lines highlights the complex balance between energy infrastructure development and farmers' concerns, as the project continues to navigate public and political opposition.
